Vedaant Lakhera
Despite the Uttar Pradesh government’s claims of rapid economic growth, the state’s traditional manufacturing industries continue to face significant challenges.
The narrow lanes of Moradabad’s Ghuiyaan Bagh echo with rhythmic metallic clinks as artisans hammer brass plates into shape. Ghuiyaan Bagh is one of the centres of Moradabad’s famous brassware industry, and its artisans have been working the trade for generations. Foremost among them is Dilshad Hussain, a legendary artisan and Moradabad’s first Padma Shri awardee. His house in Ghuiyaan Bagh is marked by a flex banner announcing his distinction. Despite being a master craftsman, Hussain is not enthusiastic about the future of the industry. “If things don’t change and the government doesn’t step in, Peetal Nagari [literally, Brass City] will be a thing of the past. I get one or two orders a month, that’s all. The whole industry might shut down in the next five to seven years,” he said with a sigh.
Uttar Pradesh has historically been one of India’s leading industrial States. Kanpur was dubbed the Manchester of the East, Firozabad the Glass City of India, and Meerut the Sports City. But the industries have declined steadily over the years. Meerut, once a flourishing scissors manufacturing hub reportedly dating back to the Mughal times, is now a ghost of its former self.
Aligarh, famed as the Lock City, has been making locks since the 1800s. Before that, its skilled artisans were forging swords and a wide range of metal hardware. But the industry today is mostly unorganised and has faced significant headwinds over the last decade. In 2016, demonetisation severely disrupted production.
Then came the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), dealing a body blow to a struggling industry. Just when the lock manufacturers were beginning to recover, the COVID-19 pandemic upended the sector once again. Gopal Varshney, general secretary of the Aligarh Locks and Hardware Association, said, “Five to 10 manufacturing units are shutting down every day. If this continues, who knows what will happen to us.”
The biggest problem, Gopal Varshney explained, is spiralling raw material prices. “The price of metal has increased by 75 per cent in the last year. Between the time a manufacturer receives an order and dispatches the finished product, the price of the raw material goes up. The price of metal might be Rs.960 today and 10 days later, it might be Rs. 1,000. The prices are increasing not at one go but on a weekly basis, throwing all our calculations into disarray. The government does not do enough to control the fluctuations,” he said.
Most manufacturers in Aligarh operate outside the formal set-up, employing no more than five workers. Many argue that the government has made little effort to formalise registration. “Many of the workers are illiterate. They are daunted by the strict procedures and think they are better off without registration,” Varshney said.
Rohit Varshney owns a small lock-manufacturing unit in Aligarh. His business is under considerable stress. “We are struggling to find adequate labour. Even if the government wants to help us, the bureaucracy is so corrupt that we are unable to access the benefits of public schemes. If the government really cares for us, as it claims, it needs to actively help the small industrialist. Otherwise, we will be left with only the Geographical Identification tag and no actual lock manufacturer.” Rohit said, adding that almost 25 per cent of the manufacturers have closed their units over the last few years.
Khurja’s plight
About 50 kilometres from Aligrah is the quaint industrial town of Khurja. It is renowned for its distinctive ceramic pottery, which has been manufactured here for generations. But in the last decade, this industry, too, has witnessed hardships.
Mohammed Jameel owns a small pottery workshop in Khurja. His father and grandfather were in the same business. Although Jameel has fared better than his father, he does not want his sons to continue the tradition. “There is no future here. We get only a handful of orders,” he said, echoing Hussain. Most ceramic producers of Khurja believe that their work is of a high quality and capable of competing with China’s. Government neglect has constrained the industry’s growth, leaving producers struggling financially.
Darshan Chhatwal, vice president of Khurja Pottery Manufacturers’ Association, narrated a story of decline similar to Gopal Varshney’s. “The pandemic, demonetisation and GST crippled the industry. In recent months, the West Asia conflict and rising oil prices have exacerbated the situation. Gas prices have surged, placing additional pressure,” he said. Chhatwal said that the industry is far behind China’s in terms of technology and production but has considerable potential in domestic and international markets. “If we enhance the quality of our products, we will be able to expand our exports. Our industry is able to capitalise on markets that are reluctant to source products from China. In order to tap into this potential further, we need new technology. The government should provide incentives for that,” he said.
Across Uttar Pradesh, manufacturers and traders confront a broader structural problem: corruption within the government machinery. In a largely unregulated sector, businesses are often compelled to factor in the costs incurred for greasing the palms of officials. The common opinion is that anyone who wants to play by the rules would go bankrupt before making their first sale.
A report titled Macro and Fiscal Landscape of the State of Uttar Pradesh released by NITI Aayog in 2025 revealed that Uttar Pradesh’s share in India’s total GDP decreased from 11.4 per cent in 1990-91 to 8.4 per cent in 2021-22. Data shared by the Union Minister for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), Jitan Ram Manjhi, also showed that the State saw the closure of 3,425 registered MSMEs between 2020 and 2024, rendering almost 33,230 people jobless.
This decline is reflected in the industrial cities’ economic turnover. In 2008-09, the peak turnover of Moradabad’s brass industry was estimated at nearly Rs.20,000 crore. According to industry associations, this figure has since fallen to approximately Rs.8,000 crore. Azam Ansari, chairman of Moradabad Brass Kharkhana Association, told Frontline that nearly 50 per cent of local artisans have shut their workshops and moved elsewhere in the last few years.
Mohammed Nadeem has been a brass artisan for the last 30 years. A third-generation artisan in Moradabad, he once operated his own workshop but, due to a prolonged lack of business, was forced to sell it and relocate to a rented space. Nadeem does not want his children to pursue the same livelihood. “I want to break this cycle. I won’t let my children do this work. There is no future in this industry. With the passage of time, no artisan will be left because, like me, nobody wants their children to enter the profession,” he said.
Communal prejudices
For artisans like Nadeem, the problems they face in Uttar Pradesh do not end with inflation and fluctuating prices. Traditional craft-based industries of the State are dominated by the Muslim working class. They have been operating in a polarised atmosphere ever since the BJP came to power at the Centre and in the State. Yameen, another artisan from Moradabad, expressed his anxieties: “All of us are dealing with a lack of business. I am not confident about taking my products to expos in, say, Bengaluru or Ahmedabad. My family would discourage me. The reason? My beard. I don’t know when an angry mob might confront and assault me.”
This is not limited to Moradabad. In Khurja, Jameel has also experienced significant losses because Muslim businesses are sought to be boycotted. “We don’t rely on conventional advertising. Our business expands through word of mouth. That is how our forefathers sustained themselves, and this is how I was sustaining myself before the Yogi Adityanath government took over the reigns of power. I have observed that people who would usually recommend my business to traders are now reluctant to do so. And this is not because the quality of my work has declined, but because my name carries a certain identity.”
Scarcity of labour is another problem cited by business owners. Most labourers now prefer to do gig work, which gives them better flexibility and short-term gains. Dilshad Hussain thinks that the flight of labour is one of the major reasons behind the decline of the brass industry. “The children of labourers would rather drive e-rickshaws or open food stalls than follow in their parents’ footsteps. When the younger generation does not carry forward the traditional occupations of their forefathers, an industry is bound to perish. But we cannot blame them because the industry itself is proving to be unprofitable,” he said.
Arun Kumar, former professor of economics at JNU, argued that the way in which the government measures growth is defective in itself. “The method by which we compile quarterly data is flawed because we project figures from the previous year onto the next year using high-frequency variables. Most of these variables are derived from the organised sector. So we end up misrepresenting the unorganised sector. There have been numerous supply bottlenecks and price increases that are not captured in the official data. These hidden factors would explain why the small units are shutting down,” he said.
He observed that government schemes rarely reach the people for whom they are intended. “People in the unorganised sector encounter considerable difficulties because many of the government schemes require formal registration. In case of jobs under the Viksit Bharat–Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin) Act, 2025, for instance, beneficiaries are required to undergo facial recognition and fingerprint authentication. But the fingerprints of many poor people have faded with years of hard labour. Moreover, machines do not function properly in rural areas,” he said.
Kumar suggested a solution, saying, “Until now, we have pursued a top-down approach to development, where benefits are expected to trickle down. But we need to embrace a bottom-up approach. There are macroeconomic reasons for this. If poor people do not possess sufficient purchasing power, demand will remain weak, and the growth of the organised sector will also decelerate. We must provide all workers with a living wage, rather than a minimum wage, and establish mechanisms to enforce it. Without effective enforcement, these provisions will remain meaningless.”
As the Uttar Pradesh Assembly election approaches, the Opposition has positioned unemployment and industrial decline as central issues in its criticism of the BJP government while Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has highlighted the economic growth recorded by Uttar Pradesh during his tenure. For artisans like Hussain or Jameel, however, all these political narratives mean nothing. All they see is a bleak future, which cannot be reversed unless the government radically intervenes to revive the ailing industries.
About the Author:
Vedaant Lakhera is a Senior Reporter with Frontline Hindu.
This article was first published in The Frontline as: When the best days are behind on September 3oth 2026.
Disclaimer: All views expressed in the article belong solely to the author and not necessarily to the organisation.
Read more at IMPRI:
18th BRICS Summit: Expectations, Challenges and the Road Ahead
BRICS+: A Strategic Opportunity for India to Shape a Multipolar World
Acknowledgement:
This article was posted by Bhargavvi Bajpai, a Research and Editorial Intern at IMPRI.




