IMPRI Team
Opening the session on Rural Realities- West Bengal, Dr. Simi Mehta, CEO & Editorial Director at IMPRI, welcomed the panelists to the session. Since the beginning of May2021, the Centre for Habitat, Urban and Regional Studies at IMPRI Impact and Policy Research Institute, New Delhi, had organized a series of sessions to discuss the rural ground realities, speaking to rural practitioners and their ways and means of tackling the second wave. On May 25, 2021, the discussion was centered on “Rural Realities | West Bengal Practitioners’ Experiences in Tackling the Second Wave in Indian Villages”.
Following the welcome by Dr. Simi, The IMPRI team informed the discussion by locating for the event participants the situation of COVID 19 in India and West Bengal. The team also provided an insight into the geography and Socio economic conditions of the state. The rationale was to provide the participants with an overview of the state of West Bengal.
Livelihood Crisis
Mr Sankar Halder, Founder President, Mukti, presented a picture on the reality of South Bengal. He started his discussion by talking about the cyclones that had devastated the region since November 2019. Coupled with the two COVID 19 waves, the dwellers in the region were facing massive devastation of livelihoods. Typically, the residents of South Bengal depended upon agriculture, fishing and government aid to survive.
Mr. Sankar, further highlighted the demographic picture of the region, where 30-35% of the residents were migrant workers. Lockdowns in cities coupled with natural disasters such as cyclones posed a livelihoods’ challenge for the locals. Migrant workers were unable to return to the cities for work.
Mr. Sankar stated that Saline water from cyclones had damaged agricultural land and washed away the dwellings. As a result, several people had fallen below the poverty line.
Mr. Sankar attributed four factors to the worsening COVID crisis in Bengal:
- crowding due to Assembly elections,
- inability of cities to effectively tackle the new wave,
- lack of infrastructure in rural areas and,
- social stigma attached to the virus.
Talking about the work being done by his organization, Mr. Sankar said that Mukti was involved in the distribution of oximeters and oxygen concentrators to make up for the deficiencies in public health infrastructure.
Lack of Medical Facilities
Mr. Tanmoy Bhaduri, Independent Journalist and Development Communication Expert, stated that the program was facing problems due to a shortage of vaccines and digital divide and glitches that marred the Co-WIN portal.
Lack of medical services such as ambulances, private nursing homes and ICU beds in rural as well as urban areas added to the woes.
Mr. Bhaduri spoke about the absence of political help as compared to last year. Only volunteers were responding to emergency calls. Further, several NGOs were facing difficulties in accessing aid to help the poor, marginalized and daily wage workers in the rural areas.
Diversion of aid to medical needs such as oxygen cylinders and concentrators made hunger invisible, said Mr. Tanmoy Bhaduri
He also highlighted the work done by him in providing adolescent girls with sanitary napkins and distributing sewing machines to manufacture the same.
Collaboration with all Stakeholders
Mr. Vikram Rai, Assistant Professor, St Joseph College, Founder Vik Run Foundation provided a perspective of the hills’ region of West Bengal, Mr. Vikram Rai attributed lack of infrastructure and social stigma to the raging pandemic in Darjeeling.
Backlog of RT-PCR test results along with the stigma attached with COVID positive patients exacerbated the pandemic situation in the region.
Talking about the donation drives generated by his foundation-Vik Run as well as his alma matter, innovation was one of the key learnings that emerged for the panelist on setting up a community care center.
The need to emphasize on wholesome healthcare-physical as well as mental- is a key ingredient to help patients recover, said Mr. Vikram Rai
For Mr. Vikram Rai, collaboration between all stakeholders- government, private medical practitioners and the civil society organizations- was necessary to combat stigma around the virus and help people recover better.
Rural poor
Shri Rajen Sundas, Trinamool Congress MLA candidate, Matigara Naxalbari, Darjeeling Talking about his experience about the tea gardens and tea workers, Shri Rajen Sundas spoke about the hesitation among the rural poor to seek treatment for the virus.
He said that the second wave had affected more poor workers compared to the previous wave.
Shri Rajen Sundas stated that there was a need for the government to collaborate with all the relevant stakeholders to battle the pandemic.
Digital Divide
Mr. Chandan Kumar Maiti, General Secretary, Advanced Society for Headmasters and Headmistresses, West Bengal, spoke about the effects of the pandemic in the Sundarbans areas. Among several notable effects were joblessness, rise in child marriages as well as trafficking, especially of the girl child.
Speaking on the divide that the pandemic has created, Mr Maiti stated that only 15% of the children can log into online classes. As a result of the digital divide, poor children were suffering from an inferiority complex. Dropouts had increased, and if the government fails to form a taskforce on this issue, then the plight of education in the country would only worsen.
High prices of treatment along with issues of social boycott prevented the rural dwellers from seeking treatment.
On the issue of rise in child marriages, Mr. Maiti stated that headmasters from across the state, along with local child protection committees undertook counselling sessions.
As for trafficking of girl child, psychological troubles, family troubles and lack of education opportunities resulted in girls getting lured by strangers into trafficking.
Poor Infrastructure
Dr. Samir Kumar Das, Professor Political Science; Director Institute of Foreign Policy Studies, University of Calcutta, Spoke about rural Bengal, Dr. Samir pointed out the two things that were given about the rural areas that:
- rural health infrastructure was poor compared to urban infrastructure and,
- it is difficult to ramp up infrastructure in a short period of time.
In a situation characterized by poor infrastructure and vaccine hesitancy in rural Bengal, it is imperative to ensure that the government controls the spread of the virus to prevent the villagers from hospitalization.
Highlighting experience of the previous wave, Dr. Samir provided four ideas through which the pandemic could be controlled in rural areas.
- First, urban areas had to be isolated from rural areas to stem the spread of the virus into non-affected regions.
- Second, the government should utilize databases recorded by religious institutions to enumerate the migrant workers.
- Third, community quarantine centers have to be re-opened to isolate the incoming workers into the villages.
- Last, rural initiatives such as rural clubs and neighborhood communities had to be mobilized to compensate for the deficiencies of government functioning. Citing the example of a Grameen library in the Sundarbans as a best practice to ensure continuation of learning, Dr. Samir stated that there was a need for more such initiatives.
Regarding questions on how best to tackle an apparent third wave,
Dr. Samir answered that many more rural and grassroots level initiatives have to come up to compensate for an inadequate public health infrastructure.
There was a need to be proactive to catch up with the virus and stem its spread.
Decentralized Approach
Dr. Binayak Sundas, Assistant Professor, Centre for Himalayan Studies, University of North Bengal, Siliguri, Darjeeling, presented a case-study of Matigara, Naxalbari. He argued for the need to adopt a decentralized approach to contain the pandemic.
A bottom- up approach initiated by local clubs had to be the basis around tackling the virus in the tea garden/ Bagan areas, said Dr. Binayak Sundas
Highlighting a four-stage program to handle the pandemic, Dr. Binayak focused on the need to create Village Action Committees (VACs).
- These committees could better communicate the needs and priorities of a particular locality.
- Second, these VACs had to be trained in basic healthcare consultations and operating the COVID war-rooms.
- The third stage required VACs to coordinate with various philanthropist groups such as the Rotary club to set up helplines and send requisite aid to the village.
- The last and fourth step revolved around the VACs capacity to act as vigilante groups and enforce lockdowns in their locality. Kin relations, especially in rural areas would ensure that rules and necessary protocols are followed effectively.
Learnings
Mr. Maiti concluded his remarks by stating that collaboration was the only means through which the pandemic woes could be reduced. Engaging the armed forces, creating national and state level policies was an imperative to tackle the pandemic.
Some of the suggestions put forth by Mr. Tanmoy Bhaduri were decentralized approach, state-level COVID management practices, regulation of fees charged by private hospitals, creating a database of district level hospitals and private nursing homes.
A humane approach was required to fight the battle rather a technical one, stated Mr. Vikram Rai.
Q & A:
On a question on education and awareness about COVID, Mr. Vikram Rai spoke about the need to localize the instructions on COVID related protocols.
Accessibility, especially in simple and easy to understand language were the necessary tools to fight the pandemic, said Mr. Vikram Rai
Citing the example of Nadia district, Mr. Tanmoy Bhaduri stated that several counsellors were in constant touch with the parents of girl children susceptible to child marriages.
On a question about trafficking, Mr. Bhaduri remarked that girls often fell prey to online miscreants. Adding to the topic of trafficking, Mr. Rai highlighted that the pandemic had turned the entire hills’ economy upside down. This would only fuel displacement and add to further miseries.
Regarding a question on Anganwadis and their role in the pandemic, Mr. Bhaduri answered that their role had been extremely limited, especially in the south Bengal region. While the ASHA workers were actively engaged in fighting the pandemic, the same was not true of Anganwadi workers.
Answering a question on a comparison between the two waves of the pandemic, Mr. Vikram Rai remarked that the second wave had generated more scare than last year. Number of deaths had considerably increased compared to last year. Due to the visibility that the virus had acquired this year, people had become aware and conscious.
Answering a question on the role of political parties during election campaigns, Dr. Binayak Sundas stated that elections did contribute to the spread in West Bengal. However, it was not the only reason.
On vaccination plans for vulnerable communities in the rural areas, Mr. Bhaduri answered that vaccine hesitancy was widely prevalent. Apart from vaccine hesitancy, vaccine shortages accompanied with distribution glitches resulted in preventing peoples’ access to the public good. Mr. Vikram Rai further remarked that tea workers had to be listed as a priority group for vaccination.
On the need to constantly monitor COVID positive patients with co-morbidities, Mr. Bhaduri remarked that the entire episode exposed the inefficiency of the government to adequately provide public health.
Mr. Vikram Rai spoke on the need to establish post-COVID care centers to address the needs of post-virus complications.
Dr. Binayak Sundas concluded the session by summarizing the ground reality of the spread in rural areas. Also, the need to constantly innovate and collaborate were the two most potent tools to emerge out of the discussions to effectively tackle the second wave.
